A study designed to determine optimal ratio of intramedullary nail diameter to tibial canal diameter that leads to reliable and timely healing in tibial shaft fractures

Authors: Dr. Rohit Kavishwar; Dr. Ravinder Lamoria; Dr. Mahesh C. Bansal; Dr. Girdhar Gopal Goyal
DIN
IMJH-SEP-2018-6
Abstract

Tibial fracture is quite common. There are various modalities to manage tibial fracture, one of them is intra-medullary nailing. This study was conducted on 100 tibial fracture patients undergoing intramedullary nailing. After operation they were followed at 3 months, 6 months , 9 months and 12 months. For 12 month followup, 90 patients were available. So 90 patients were used to determine optimal ratio of intramedullary nail diameter to tibial canal diameter at the isthmus that leads to reliable and timely healing in tibial shaft fractures. It can be concluded from this study that non union rate was significantly less in the patients having optimal ratio(0.8 to 0.99mm) of tibia nail to medullary cavity width at the isthmus than the other group having ratio less than 0.8mm or more than 0.99mm. So optimal ratio of tibia nail to medullary cavity width at the isthmus was found 0.8 mm to 0.99mm.

Keywords
Tibial fracture intramedullary nailing RUST Functional Outcome.
Introduction

Fractures of the leg bones are the most common long bone fracture. In an average population, there are about 26 tibial diaphyseal fractures per 100,000 population per year. 1 Men are more commonly affected than women, with the male incidence about 41 per 100,000 per year and the female incidence about 12 per 100,000 per year. The average age of patients sustaining a tibia shaft fractures is 37 years with men having an average age of 31 years and women 54 years.1 

The management of tibial diaphyseal fractures has always held a particular interest for orthopaedic surgeons.2 Fractures of the shaft of the tibia cannot be treated by following a simple set of rules. Most fractures of tibia will heal if treated by non-operative means — this fact is undeniable.3 

The shaft of tibia is subcutaneous throughout its length and may have a diminished blood supply, severe complications and major disability are common outcomes.4 Fractures of the tibia and fibula can range from completely undisplaced fractures with minimal soft tissue damage to traumatic amputations. The treatment modalities described for tibia and fibula fractures range from simple cast immobilization to complex surgical procedures4 

Operative treatment is indicated for most tibial fractures caused by high-energy trauma. These fractures usually are unstable, comminuted, and associated with varying degrees of soft-tissue trauma. Operative treatment allows early motion, provides soft-tissue access, and avoids complications associated with immobilization. The goals of treatment are to obtain a healed, well-aligned fracture; pain-free weight bearing; and functional range of motion of the knee and ankle joints.

Conclusion

It can be concluded from this study that non union rate was significantly less in the patients having optimal ratio (0.8 to 0.99) of tibia nail to medullary cavity width at the isthmus than the other group having ratio less than 0.8 or more than 0.99. So optimal ratio of tibia nail to medullary cavity width at the isthmus was found 0.8 mm to 0.99mm.

Article Preview